Skip to Content

25 Delicious Ice Cream Pie Recipes

Sharing is caring!

I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream! 25 of the most delicious ice cream pie recipes in one place! There are no calories for looking!

It is safe to say I  am a true lover of ice cream.  I would pick ice cream before most other desserts.  This round-up 25 of the most delicious ice cream pie recipes.  I promise there are no calories for just looking! Save your favorites for special moments, special birthdays, special anything.  Which one is your favorite in the bunch?

25 ice cream pie recipes

Ice Cream Pie Recipes

Oreo Ice Cream Pie at The Baker Mama

If you are an Oreo fan you have to try this Oreo Ice Cream Pie. This would be an incredible dessert to make for a birthday party, potluck or more.

oreo ice cream pie

Mississippi Mud Ice Cream Pie at Six Sister’s Stuff

Layers of incredible flavor is what you will find in this Mississippi Mud inspired ice cream cake. This would be the talk of the party for sure. Make this on a hot summer day and enjoy the rich and cool flavors.

Mississippi-Mud-Ice-Cream-Pie-on-SixSistersStuff.com_-683x1024

Chocolate Candy Bar Ice Cream Pie at Chocolate, Chocolate and More

Calling all candy bar lovers, give this chocolate candy bar ice cream pie a try. It is loaded with chocolate flavor so every bite feels sinfully decadent.

Chocolate-Candy-Bar-Ice-Cream-Pie-from-ChocolateChocolateandmore-39a

Raspberry Ice Cream Pie at Butter with a Side of Bread

A rich and velvety smooth raspberry-filled ice cream pie that is topped with fresh raspberries so every bite is a fruit-filled delight. If you don’t love chocolate, try this raspberry version.

raspberryicecreampie13

Easy Mint Chip Cream Pie at The Cookie Rookie

This classic mint chip cream pie is one of my favorites. There is something about mint ice cream that always hits the spot. This mint chip is going to be refreshing, sweet and hit your sweet tooth cravings.

mintfeature

Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie at Two Peas and their Pod

I love this for fall, a pumpkin ice cream pie that has a crunchy graham cracker crust and loads of pumpkin flavor in every sweet and creamy bite you take.

5-Ingredient-Pumpkin-Ice-Cream-Pie-6

Peanut Butter Rice Krispie Ice Cream Pie at The Sugar Hit

This pie right here is one to serve up to guests for an incredible and stunning presentation. While it looks gorgeous it tastes even better. Creamy and crunchy in every single bite.

Peanut-Butter-Rice-Krispie-Ice-Cream-Pie-4

Banana Split Ice Cream Pie at Will Cook for Smiles

If you love a classic banana split this pie is right up your alley. Fresh strawberries, banana, and sweet pineapple that is drizzled with chocolate, whipped cream and more.

Banana-Split-Ice-Cream-Pie-1

Chocolate-Raspberry Ice Cream Pie at Delish

Chocolate and raspberry collide in this delightful pie recipe. You can serve this for Valentine’s Day, birthdays, or even a summer or spring dessert. This ice cream pie is perfect any time of the year. 

chocolate-raspberry-ice-cream-pie-recipe-lg

Funfetti Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie at Beyond Frosting

If sprinkles and the flavor of funfetti are your things this funfettic cookie dough pie is going to be a show-stopping treat. I absolutely love the flavors of this ice cream pie.

funfetti cookie dough pie

Caramel Toffee Ice Cream Pie at Ashley Marie

Rich caramel toffee on a golden graham cracker crust. If you want to try out a toffee inspired ice cream pie, you have to try this out. She has tons of great recipes on her blog.

caramel toffee pie

Frozen Turtle Pie at Southern Plate

Chocolate, pecans, and caramel join forces in this rich turtle inspired pie. I whip this up for my husband for our anniversary or birthday and he goes nuts every single time.

frozen-turtle-pie-watermarked-1024x768

Coffee Toffee Ice Cream Pie at Eat at Home

Love a good coffee dessert? Me too! This coffee toffee is a killer on flavor, a nice crunch, and hard to resist one more slice. Whip this up and watch your family do backflips.

coffee-toffee-ice-cream-pie-done

Oatmeal Cream Pie Ice Cream Pie at Beyond Frosting

Here is a really unique and creative ice cream pie. If you love the classic oatmeal cream pie then enjoy this rich, and creamy oatmeal cream pie dessert.

oatmeal cream pie

Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pie with Miso Caramel Apples at Nada Moo

Rich, sweet, and tender caramel apples in every single bite. This salted caramel brings out so much flavor in your ice cream pie. If you want something unique and creative try this out. 

salted caramel miso apples

Blueberry Coconut Ice Cream Pie at Blahnik Baker

Fresh blueberries and coconut shavings top this incredibly luscious blueberry coconut ice cream pie. A really refreshing and tropical twist of flavors in this recipe.

Blueberry-Coconut-Ice-Cream-Pie-3

Banana Cream Pie Ice Cream at Lady Behind the Curtain

Rich layers of crust, banana, cream in a sweet ice cream pie recipe. If you love a classic banana pie you will really love this ice cream pie version.

Banana-Cream-Pie-Ice-Cream-Lady-Behind-The-Curtain-1

Cinnamon Bun Ice Cream Pie at Ready to Yumble

I love a good cinnamon bun so when I saw this version of ice cream pie I knew I had to share it. This is full of nice spiced flavor in each bite.

Cinnamon-Bun-Ice-Cream-Pie-2-2

Berries and Cream Ice Cream Pie at Joy Filled Eats

Berries and ice cream are such a dynamic duo and this ice pie does not disappoint. Whip this up for a crowd for one incredible treat to the end of the day. berries ice cream pie

Gone Fishin’ S’mores Ice Cream Pie at Hostess at Heart

This blue ocean gone fishing pie. It is even topped with a golden graham goldfish or a nice crush and look to the pie!

Gone-Fishin-Smores-Ice-Cream-Pie-6

Chocolate Chip Cookie Crusted Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie at Wine and Glue

Cookie dough lovers cheer from the stands as you dive into this sweet creation. I highly recommend whipping this up as a birthday treat, after school snack and more.



Oreo and Heath Ice Cream Pie at Chin Deep

Oreo and Health combine for one crunchy and sweet pie recipe. I made this over the summer and it won over the whole family.

heathpie-DSC07318

Banana Split Ice Cream Pie (in a jar!) at Around My Family Table

Grab a jar and create a really fun and sweet ice cream pie that is so tasty and delicious. Single servings to pass out to family and friends.

banana-splits-3-800

Drumstick Ice Cream Pie at The View from Great Island

Everything about this Drumstick Ice Cream Pie has me saying yes over and over again. I love a Drumstick so this is on my agenda to make.

drumstick-Ice-Cream-Pie-3489-May-09-2016-6

Easy Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie at Cookie Rookie

Rich, chocolatey, peanut butter, all come together for one outstanding and easy pie. You can make this for any chocolate and peanut butter fan.

peanut-butter-cup-ice-cream-pie-6

Sharing is caring!

Snowmen S'mores Mix
Snowmen S'mores Mix
← Read Last Post
Instant Pot Cranberry Moonshine
Instant Pot Cranberry Moonshine
Read Next Post →